www.rewireviews.com (retrieved from wayback machine)
The Church's Marty Willson-Piper Talks about...
Chicago, April 19, 2002.

Pay little attention. Marty isn't saying much.
Photo by ea01.

Marty Willson-Piper agreed to talk to us while record-shopping at Tower Records immediately after The Church played an in-store session of five songs--a bonus for the audience as only three were originally planned. At the onset, Marty wanted to prove his credentials for being top of the class at the school where they teach people like him, and singer/bassist Steven Kilbey, the art of elusiveness.
Walking through the CD racks, first he tells of And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead.
Marty Willson-Piper: Yeah, I do have just the new album...it's quite good.
RewiReviews: What have you been hooked onto recently? (Initially, I thought Marty wasn't going to condescend and tell me who he listens to. Later, I learned from guitarist Peter Koppes that Marty owns a massive CD collection.)
Marty: I buy so many records. I tend to listen to lots of different things [in less than ten minutes, he had collected fourteen CD's to buy, and counting.] I've been listening to Zeppelin boot-legs, actually. Someone copied me about six Zeppelin bootlegs, so I've been listening to them. Beautiful guitarist.
RR: Jimmy Page?
Marty: Yeah, I've been listening to Lil' Kim; also Neil Finn and Alicia Keys.
RR: You're pulling my leg!
Marty: No, Alicia Keys is brilliant. She sounds like Todd Rundgren but no one's made that connection yet.
RR: Would you like to write her a couple of songs?
Marty: No, no, no. I'm not in her league! What are you talking about?
RR: Crossing boundaries can be fun?
Marty: Yeah, yeah. But you know...

Continuing his shopping extravaganza, Marty tells more about what he thinks.
Marty: I like The White Stripes. I listen to Black Rebel Motorcycle Club--I had that record long before anybody heard about it. I bought the single when it was first reviewed. Andrew WK, he's hilarious. How is that that here in America they blocked the cover image?
RR: Actually, it started in the UK first, not the US.
Marty: Really! I bought it before it was controversial. Sheryl Crow, to me she's the female Tom Petty. She's exactly the same. I've got the Pete Yorn album?I gave it a good listen. I've got the Elbow album too. Surely, you do not want to hear The Strokes again! Surely, not again! It's just that they're overplayed.
RR: Not in Texas they're not.
Marty: In New York they are. That's where I live now.

RR: Do you know who Ryan Adams is?
Marty: Oh God!
RR: You know he re-recorded the entire Strokes album.
Marty: I thought it was pretty funny.
RR: It's not meant to be released, you know.
Marty: I hope it does. I'd definitely buy that.

I tried to steer him into talking about himself and the band, but that would prove to be an arduous task.
RR: It seems that you like paradoxical things?
Marty: [disregarding the question] Ben Harper, I love Ben Harper.


Steve Kilby can now play with eyes closed.
Photo by ea01.
RR: What about paradoxical things?
Marty: What do you mean? You mean I like Black Sabbath and then Lil' Kim? Yes.
RR: What about things out of music...in daily life?
Marty: No. I don't like paradoxical things out of music. Music is the only thing where I like opposites.
RR: Simple, straight forward then?
Marty: I didn't say it was simple!
RR: Well, tell me more about life.
Marty: Life sucks. Everybody should kill themselves. [Jokingly and cynical, Marty also seemed embittered.]
RR: Really! How come you're still alive?
Marty: 'Cause I failed lots of times. [This time he laughs whimsically.]
RR: What about your best show? Your happiest moment? When do you feel like you want to kick someone in the ass?
Marty: I never feel extra happy and I never feel I want to kick somebody in the ass.
RR: Never?
Marty: No.
RR: It's not a bad symptom to have. (I was trying to get him to say more but...)
Marty: No.

Percussionist Tim Powles
Photo by ea01.

Guitarist Peter Koppes
Photo by Patrick Rose

Earlier, I had a brief talk with Steven Kilbey.
RR: After Everything Now This. What's after this?
Steven: Detroit
RR: What about the horizon?
Steven: Horizon? Nervous breakdown. Fucking book it in. Try on our night off. [I couldn't tell if it was embittered, cynical, or both.]

Back to Marty, I decided to change the subject and ask him about After Everything Now This.
RR: This album has been written and recorded over three continents. How does the writing work within The Church?
Marty: It's a big jam session, you know. It's all that is--just a big jam session. The reason we still do what we do is because when we get into a room and jam, it just works.

RR: Flawlessly?
Marty: It just comes out, you know. We don't have to work too hard on it. There's a reason for sticking together and... [he seemed hesitant as if searching for the right word]...and we do and it's just like making love, you know. You should try making love and see what that's like. [I have, but thanks for the advice anyway, Marty.]
RR: If there's anything better than making love, God has kept it to himself! Marty: Look, it's all a metaphor for communication. [He repeated himself. Finally, he was beginning to open up.] And the whole point is to communicate and make something work. And if you communicate and make something work, then that's the reason to continue to do it, isn't it?

RR: What is it that you're trying to communicate then?
Marty: I don't care about what I communicate to people. [So much for lack of paradox in real life!] I don't care about what I communicate to people I create with. What the people get is irrelevant. As soon as you start caring about what people get, then you're in big trouble. Then you start designing yourself for somebody else. And what's that? That's nonsense. That's why relationships fail [emphatically and unstoppable now.] Because you start designing yourself for the other person instead of yourself. That's not the way to do it. You ought to do everything to be yourself without being selfish. That's the clever stuff


Maybe I'll sing instead.
Photo by Patrick Rose

RR: twenty-two years later, and sixteen records, has it been a good ride?
Marty: It doesn't seem like a ride! Ride [rather offended]! Is that the right word for it?

That was the end of that subject. He talked about a couple of records, including Ed Harcourt's, then...
Marty: You see, I believe reviews. When it says it's good, I know it's bad and when it says it's bad, I know it's good. [There was a reference there to Uncut's review of After Everything Now This, which wasn't received favorably.]
Marty talked for a while about magazines and reviews, but I wanted to steer him back to our previous topic.
RR: What is it that you want to communicate through The Church?
Marty: Nothing.
RR: Through yourself? Marty: Nothing at all!
RR: Through your guitar?
Marty: Nothing.
RR: Well, when is there something you want to communicate?
Marty: When somebody comes up to me and says, "I like that."
RR: I already said I like After Everything Now This?
Marty: Then, we've communicated.

My time with Marty was limited to that (and his explaining to me the new philosophy of Marty and the Art of Ambiguity). After the show at Chicago's House of Blues, Peter Koppes shed a little more light. "We dreamt we were going to affect people that way. We cannot stop, that's all."
-ea01
[edited by koolthing]


Back to interviews